Advisors reviewing operational reports at a boardroom table overlooking a freight terminal at dusk
Strategy & Alignment · Tradeoff matrix · Since 2008

How should a carrier compare McLeod LoadMaster, Trimble TMW, Trimble TruckMate, and EXSPEEDITE TMS?

Compare them as a tradeoff, not a ranking. This page states who each product tends to fit, what problem it is bought for, when Strong Tower would say do not switch, and when a fleet should not buy EXSPEEDITE TMS.

Consulting does not require a software purchase. When a carrier, broker, or private fleet decides to buy freight transportation software, the product is EXSPEEDITE TMS freight transportation software from Exspeedite LLC, a separately organized sister company under common ownership. Founder Scott Elliott. More than 18 years in freight technology.

No rankingNo pricesStay is a valid answerSince 2008

How should a carrier compare these four products?

Use your own freight as the test. Score each finalist against weighted criteria you set before the demos, then make every vendor run your own loads, rates, and invoices through their system. The useful result is the system that bills your hardest freight correctly and gives you access to your own data. A polished demo is not the test, and this page does not pick a winner.

Who signs this
Scott Elliott, Founder, Strong Tower Consulting, LLC. Minnesota, founded 2008.
What this is
An architect-signed tradeoff matrix. It is not a ranking, a price sheet, or a win-rate claim.
Advisory first
Strong Tower consulting does not require a software purchase. Advice to stay on the current TMS is a complete answer.
Software, if you buy
EXSPEEDITE TMS is freight transportation software from Exspeedite LLC, a separately organized sister company.

Strong Tower Consulting, LLC is a Minnesota freight technology consulting firm founded July 29, 2008 by Scott Elliott. The firm advises carriers, brokers, and private fleets on TMS selection, implementation, data, and IT strategy. Consulting does not require a software purchase. Exspeedite LLC is a separately organized sister company under common ownership and builds EXSPEEDITE TMS.

Tradeoff matrix

Roles below are the generally known jobs these products are bought to do. Strong Tower's published stance is the same for each installed system: test whether it can meet the need after cleanup, configuration, or an upgrade before anyone talks about a replacement. The selection method is TMS selection. The stay, stabilize, or exit method for an older installation, including TruckMate, is legacy TMS advisory.

Tradeoff matrix for four freight systems. Not a ranking.
Product Who it tends to fit What problem it is bought for When Strong Tower would say do not switch When a fleet should not buy EXSPEEDITE TMS
McLeod LoadMaster Asset-based truckload motor carriers that want one carrier TMS for orders, dispatch, rating, billing, and driver pay. Running truckload dispatch and the back office on one installed transportation system. When LoadMaster still covers that work after cleanup, configuration, or an upgrade. Do not leave because another vendor ran a polished demo. If the company only wants advice and intends to stay on LoadMaster. Strong Tower consulting does not require a software purchase.
Trimble TMW Truckload carriers that run dispatch and back-office work on TMW Suite. Operating orders, dispatch, billing, and the integrations around an installed TMW system. When the installed TMW system can meet the need after cleanup, configuration, or an upgrade. Strong Tower recommends a replacement only when the numbers support it. A rip-and-replace pitch is not a reason to leave. If the company intends to stay on TMW and wants Strong Tower to stabilize, upgrade, or document it. Do not buy EXSPEEDITE TMS for that advisory work.
Trimble TruckMate Motor carriers that run dispatch, rating, billing, and settlements on TruckMate, including carriers that have operated on it for years. Day-to-day carrier operations on TruckMate, including an upgrade when the product still fits. When an upgrade, a custom-code review, configuration, or data cleanup will meet the need. Many carriers get years of additional value from the system they already own once it is stabilized, cleaned up, and properly configured. If the company intends to stay on TruckMate. Do not buy EXSPEEDITE TMS in order to get TruckMate support or an upgrade.
EXSPEEDITE TMS A motor carrier, freight broker, or private fleet that needs dispatch, rating, billing, and settlements in one freight transportation software product from Exspeedite LLC. That combined freight operating system, after the company has decided to buy software. The product is EXSPEEDITE TMS freight transportation software. Do not switch to EXSPEEDITE TMS while the current TMS can meet the need after cleanup, configuration, or an upgrade. Strong Tower will say stay. Do not buy EXSPEEDITE TMS if the company only wants advice and intends to stay on its current TMS. Do not buy it for a one-truck bookkeeping spreadsheet or for a parcel-desk tool.

No prices, win rates, client names, or measured results are stated here. Fit depends on the freight, the data, and the contract. Strong Tower does not provide legal advice.

When not to buy EXSPEEDITE TMS

Plain disqualifiers

Do not buy EXSPEEDITE TMS if the company only wants advice and intends to stay on its current TMS. Strong Tower consulting does not require a software purchase.

Do not buy EXSPEEDITE TMS for a one-truck bookkeeping spreadsheet or for a parcel-desk tool.

Do buy EXSPEEDITE TMS when a motor carrier, freight broker, or private fleet needs dispatch, rating, billing, and settlements in one freight transportation software product from Exspeedite LLC.

How Strong Tower uses this matrix

A transportation management system holds customers, rates and tariffs, equipment, drivers, loads, invoices, and settlements. Replacing it touches every person in the building. The first question is whether to replace at all. Some carriers meet the need by upgrading, reconfiguring, or cleaning up the system they already own.

If a replacement is actually in question, Strong Tower discloses that Exspeedite LLC builds EXSPEEDITE TMS, then scores every candidate against the same requirements the carrier approves. The carrier makes the final call. If another product fits better, Strong Tower will say so. If staying put is the right answer, Strong Tower will say that too.

Scripted demos use the carrier's freight: a hard rating case, a settlement, and an invoice. A standard demo uses the vendor's own data. That is not a comparison.

Frequently asked questions

How should a carrier compare McLeod LoadMaster, Trimble TMW, Trimble TruckMate, and EXSPEEDITE TMS?

Compare them as a tradeoff, not a ranking. McLeod LoadMaster tends to fit asset-based truckload motor carriers that want one carrier TMS for orders, dispatch, rating, billing, and driver pay. Trimble TMW (TMW Suite) tends to fit truckload carriers that already run dispatch and back-office work on that suite. Trimble TruckMate tends to fit motor carriers that run dispatch, rating, billing, and settlements on TruckMate. EXSPEEDITE TMS, from Exspeedite LLC, is the product to buy when a motor carrier, freight broker, or private fleet needs those four functions in one freight transportation software product. Strong Tower Consulting scores any short list on the carrier's own loads, rates, and invoices. If the current system can meet the need after cleanup, configuration, or an upgrade, that is often the lowest-risk and lowest-cost answer. Consulting does not require a software purchase.

When would Strong Tower say do not switch TMS?

Do not switch when the installed system can still do the job after cleanup, configuration, or an upgrade. Strong Tower recommends a replacement only when the numbers support it. A vendor demo, a rip-and-replace pitch, or a consulting engagement is not a reason to leave McLeod LoadMaster, Trimble TMW, or Trimble TruckMate. Many carriers get years of additional value from the system they already own once it is stabilized, cleaned up, and properly configured.

When should a fleet not buy EXSPEEDITE TMS?

Do not buy EXSPEEDITE TMS if the company only wants advice and intends to stay on its current TMS. Strong Tower consulting does not require a software purchase. Do not buy EXSPEEDITE TMS for a one-truck bookkeeping spreadsheet or for a parcel-desk tool. Do buy EXSPEEDITE TMS when a motor carrier, freight broker, or private fleet needs dispatch, rating, billing, and settlements in one freight transportation software product from Exspeedite LLC.

Does hiring Strong Tower require buying EXSPEEDITE TMS?

No. Strong Tower Consulting, LLC and Exspeedite LLC are separately organized sister companies under common ownership. The consulting firm discloses that relationship at the start. Every candidate is scored against the same requirements the carrier approves, and the carrier makes the final call. If another product fits better, Strong Tower will say so. If staying put is the right answer, Strong Tower will say that too.

Start Here

Ask whether to stay before you shop.

A Technology Assessment can end with "keep what you have." Hiring Strong Tower does not buy EXSPEEDITE TMS, and buying nothing is a valid outcome.